skip to content
My Green Pod Logo

Bad news for haddock…

...But American lobster claws its way up the latest seafood ratings lists
Bad news for haddock

The latest seafood ratings on the Marine Conservation Society’s (MCS) Good Fish Guide website have seen three haddock fisheries in the North Sea and West of Scotland area downgraded due to a change in scientific advice, meaning it’s no longer on the charity’s recommended green list of fish to eat.

Updated advice

Haddock is a popular choice with seafood consumers and a favourite at the chip shop. It’s one of the UK’s ‘Big 5’ fish species along with cod, tuna, salmon and prawns.

Two North Sea haddock fisheries are now rated 4 (amber) and the other has dropped from being a good choice (rated 2) to one to eat only occasionally (rated 3).

‘These ratings changes have come about because scientific perception of the stock has changed. Compared with 2015, the stock numbers in 2016 were below the recommended level and at the point where action is now needed to increase the number of fish of breeding age.’

MCS Good Fish Guide Manager

The Marine Conservation Society has updated its comprehensive set of advice in the Good Fish Guide and, although fisheries for haddock are doing less well than in previous years, other seafood choices are looking more positive.

Scampi and lobster

Nephrops, commonly known as scampi, from Farn Deeps fishery has been re-rated from a 5 (a fish to avoid) to a 4 in recognition of improved management – and although it’s some way off being sustainable, it’s a step in the right direction

There were also improvements for scampi fisheries in the west of Scotland, Clyde and Jura catch areas.

The guide also includes new ratings from further afield. American lobster (Homarus americanus) caught on the Canadian side of the Atlantic and in the Northeast US (Gulf of Maine and George’s Bank fisheries) has become more common and even clawed its way into UK supermarkets at Christmas.

‘Remember to choose fish from Marine Stewardship Council certified fisheries when choosing American lobster (green rated 2). These generally implement stronger management methods to protect the stocks, habitat and to avoid the bycatch of endangered species.’

MCS Good Fish Guide Manager


Squid, often called calamari on the menu, has been experiencing mixed fortunes globally. Populations appear to be increasing in the North Sea, but the Argentine shortfin squid – the second-biggest squid fishery in the world – has seen huge decreases in landings and 2016 prices increased by 30% compared with the end 2015.

Although squid is a fast-growing species and an important predator and prey species, they’re also very sensitive to environmental changes. These global swings in squid populations could be down to El Niño, which this year has had a real impact on ocean temperatures.

MCS says that, going forward, squid must be monitored and the level of fishing adapted appropriate to the population sizes in any specific year.

Sustainable tuna

As a group, tuna are one of the UK’s five most popular fish to eat, and the UK is the second-largest importer of tuna in the world. The variety available makes choosing tuna complicated, and the level of detail given on the Good Fish Guide enables the consumer to make a sustainable choice.

Yellowfin from the Indian Ocean is a major source of tuna for the UK, mainly sold as fresh or chilled steaks – but the stock is overfished and not well managed. Red ratings remain for longline, purse seine and gill net fisheries. Even with commitments to recover the stock, levels are not expected to recover the fishery to sustainable levels within 10 years.

However, it is good news for North Atlantic albacore. The longline and pelagic trawl fisheries for this stock have improved from a 4 to a 3 and a 3 to a 2 for troll and pole & line fisheries. New stock assessments have revealed the population has recovered to a healthy level after previously being overfished. South Atlantic albacore has also seen similar improvements.

Bigeye tuna in the East Pacific Ocean, on the other hand, has been downgraded from a 3 to a 4 for the purse seine and longline fisheries because the stock is now in an overfished state.

Click here to see the complete seafood ratings in the Good Fish Guide.

Here's more related content

Sorry we don't have any suggested related content at the moment. Please check back later.

Join The Conversation

Leave a Reply

Here's More Ethical Food & Drink News & Features

  • All
  • Alcohol
  • EVs
  • Fairtrade
  • Spirits
  • activists
  • agroforestry
  • alcohol-free
  • beauty
  • biodiversity
  • carbon
  • celebrity
  • circular economy
  • climate change
  • climate justice
  • coffee
  • community
  • consciousness
  • conservation
  • cooking
  • dairy
  • diet
  • drink
  • drinks
  • education
  • energy
  • environment
  • ethical business
  • events
  • farmers
  • farming
  • farms
  • fashion
  • fishing
  • floods
  • food
  • food waste
  • garden
  • growing
  • health
  • home
  • human rights
  • investment
  • lifestyle
  • local
  • marine protection
  • natural beauty
  • natural products
  • net zero
  • oceans
  • organic
  • packaging
  • pets
  • plastic-free
  • plastics
  • recipe
  • recycling
  • renewables
  • reuse
  • schools
  • shopping
  • skincare
  • soil
  • spirituality
  • supply chain
  • textiles
  • travel
  • upcycle
  • vegan
  • waste
  • water
  • wellbeing
  • wind
  • wind power
  • zero waste